• @octopus_ink@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    It was in a batch specifically meant for Hezbollah operatives.

    Yes, I understand that. And those Hezbollah operatives can lose their pagers, have them stolen, or they themselves can move randomly through populated areas with the hidden bomb strapped to their hip. You don’t think any of these “operatives” do anything but sit all day in a cartoon-style bad guy lair surrounded by other bad guys? They never go to buy groceries, or stop at a hospital or school, or have their devices stolen or lost in some random location? As I have said repeatedly, these devices were deployed in a manner that has absolutely no mechanism by which to control where they actually are and who else is in proximity to them when detonated.

    Either we are just incapable of communicating effectively with each other, or you are being intentionally obtuse.

    Again I say good day to you.

    • @CerealKiller01@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      1
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      And those Hezbollah operatives can lose their pagers

      And you can lose your car keys. But if someone asked you where they were, you wouldn’t say “Oh, they’re in a random place”.

      or they themselves can move randomly through populated areas with the hidden bomb strapped to their hip

      The explosive charge was small enough to seriously harm only those who are in direct contact with it. There’s a video of one charge going off in the middle of grocery shopping (speaking of your next point) with a person standing maybe 20 cm next to the explosion. That person was able to run away without apparent harm.

      They never go to buy groceries, or stop at a hospital or school, or have their devices stolen or lost in some random location

      There’s no method of warfare that would never harm civilians.

      a manner that has absolutely no mechanism by which to control where they actually are and who else is in proximity to them when detonated.

      The pagers being bought by Hezbollah is the mechanism. Did you mean a real-time mechanism? Is this what it boils down to? Edit: Sorry, I misread what you said. Changing my reply to: As you can see from the video, where they are and who is next to them isn’t really a factor. I would agree that if they are in very close proximity to another person (hugging them of maybe riding in a crowded public transport), the explosion will probably harm the other person. Once again, relative to other methods aimed against targets operating among civilian population, this seems more selective, not less.