• arthurpizza
    link
    fedilink
    English
    476 months ago

    Is it though?

    • You’re still going to need rail workers to make sure the tracks are healthy.
    • The cost of a fleet of these self-standing pods versus one or two older decommissioned trains It’s about the same price.

    I’m struggling to see any benefit here.

    • MxM111
      link
      fedilink
      246 months ago

      If ridership is low, you can’t run train often. And if you can’t run it often, people will not use it. It just does not work. This one has chance to work, since essentially you can run it on demand, like Uber.

      • arthurpizza
        link
        fedilink
        English
        66 months ago

        Sounds like they need a shuttle bus which would be a TON cheaper and more efficient.

        • poVoqOPM
          link
          fedilink
          14
          edit-2
          6 months ago

          No, these pods on existing rails are potentially a TON cheaper. Even if you don’t count the cost of maintaining the road (which is significantly more than maintaining rail tracks), the need for paying a driver makes most small shuttle bus services prohibitively expensive.

            • bluGill
              link
              fedilink
              66 months ago

              In this case the rails are already there but unused.

              That is also several strike against this. Those rails exist but they are all in really bad shape as they were nearly universally used without maintenance until it was no longer feasible. They are also generally in bad areas where there isn’t much need for more transport - we already have roads in good shape (to run a bus on). The only thing this has over a bus is you can run them fully automated - which isn’t enough IMO.

              • CrimeDadA
                link
                fedilink
                English
                46 months ago

                I think part of what makes tracks unusable for regular trains is when the rails become too misaligned. Of course that isn’t an issue for a vehicle that only requires one rail. I kind of like this idea.

            • poVoqOPM
              link
              fedilink
              46 months ago

              The tracks are also already there, and gyroscope stabilized monorail is a 100+ year old technology, not much new to develop about it other than using modern battery technology and some basic self-driving features for it.